Abstract
This study addresses the widespread issues of "substituting fines for criminal penalties" and "imbalance in sentencing" in the punishment of food safety crimes. It delves into the root cause, which lies in the critical gap between the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China and the Food Safety Law of the People's Republic of China. This study first highlights the specific manifestations of the poor connection between the two laws. Firstly, the misalignment of the crime classification system results in some serious food safety violations not being accurately categorized under the appropriate criminal charges. Secondly, the conflict in legal terminology leads to ambiguities and inconsistencies in defining key concepts, affecting the uniformity of legal application. Thirdly, the imbalance in the allocation of penalties is evident in the overly broad range of statutory penalties and the lack of clear gradation, failing to accurately match the severity of the criminal acts and the perpetrator's malice. Additionally, the absence of targeted punitive measures, such as disqualification penalties, significantly weakens the deterrent effect of the law. To address these issues, this study proposes systematic recommendations for optimizing the penalty gradient, reconstructing the crime classification system to tighten the criminal law net and ensure accurate characterization of harmful acts, refining the penalty gradient by scientifically setting a clear and balanced range of statutory penalties based on the nature of the act, its consequences, and the perpetrator's subjective elements, and introducing disqualification penalties and punitive compensation systems to enhance the deterrent effect through the deprivation of reoffending ability and economic penalties.
Publication Date
11-19-2025
First Page
48
Last Page
51
DOI
10.13652/j.spjx.1003.5788.2025.60134
Recommended Citation
Mi, LI
(2025)
"Research on penalty gradient optimization for food safety crimes,"
Food and Machinery: Vol. 41:
Iss.
10, Article 7.
DOI: 10.13652/j.spjx.1003.5788.2025.60134
Available at:
https://www.ifoodmm.cn/journal/vol41/iss10/7
References
[1] 中共中央办公厅、国务院办公厅印发 《关于进一步强化食品安全全链条监管的意见 》[J].职业,2025 (4):27.The general office of the CPC central committee and the general office of the state council issued the opinions on further strengthening the whole chain supervision of food safety [J].Occupational,2025 (4):27.
[2] 董 超.最 大 程 度 保 障 “舌 尖 上 的 安 全 ”[N].保 健 时 报,2025 -04-17(2).DONG C.Ensuring the safety of food on the tip of the tongue to the greatest extent [N].Health Times,2025 -04-17(2).
[3] 李祖兴,张向东.罪责衡平与刑罚梯度之完善:以贪污贿赂犯罪为视角 [J].山西省政法管理干部学院学报,2018,31(4):67-70.LI Z X,ZHANG X D.Perfection of guilty balance and penalty gradient:from the perspective of corruption and bribery [J].Journal of Shanxi Politics and Law Institute for Administrators,2018,31(4):67-70.
[4] 张伟珂,周晓为.危害食品安全犯罪刑法评价的三个维度 [J].人民检察,2024 (12):53-56.ZHANG W K.ZHOU X W.Three dimensions of criminal law evaluation on food safety crimes [J].People's Procuratirial Semimonthly,2024 (12):53-56.
[5] 杨 牧 飞.从 刑 法 角 度 论 述 食 品 安 全 问 题 [J].中 国 盐 业,2023(24):45-48.YANG M F.On food safety from the perspective of criminal law[J].China Salt Industry,2023 (24):45-48.
[6] 宋 睿,郝 志 学,吕 学 泽.特 殊 食 品 刑 法 保 障 体 系 研 究 与 探 析[J].中国食品药品监管,2024 (8):72-77.SONG R,HAO Z X,LV X Z.Research and study on the criminal law protection system for special foodstuffs [J].China Food and Drug Administration,2024 (8):72-77.
[7] 魏卓然.食品安全犯罪刑法规制的思考分析 [J].中国食品工业,2023 (5):28-29.WEI Z R.Analysis on the criminal regulation of food safety crimes [J].China Food Industry,2023 (5):28-29.
[8] 邱陵,戴小强.食品安全犯罪的司法扩张与理论缩限 [J].江西警察学院学报,2022 (4):93-100.QIU L,DAI X Q.Judicial expansion and theoretical limitation of food safety crime [J].Journal of Jiangxi Police College,2022(4):93-100.
[9] 但 雨 珂,陈 航.食 品 安 全 刑 法 保 护 机 制 的 完 善 路 径 研 究:评《论食品安全的刑法保护 》[J].食品安全质量检测学报,2022,13(9):3 049.DAN Y H,CHEN H.Research on the improvement path of the criminal law protection mechanism for food safety:review of "on the criminal law protection of food safety" [J].Journal of Food Safety & Quality,2022,13(9):3 049.
[10] 刘申时.食品药品安全犯罪侦查的困境与应对策略探究:评《食 品 药 品 安 全 犯 罪 的 刑 法 规 制 》[J].食 品 安 全 质 量 检 测 学报,2022,13(9):3 050.LIU S S.Dilemmas and countermeasures in food and drug safety crime investigation:review of "criminal regulation of food and drug safety crime" [J].Journal of Food Safety & Quality,2022,13(9):3 050.