•  
  •  
 

Corresponding Author(s)

冯涛（1969—），男，北京工商大学教授，博士。E-mail：fengt@th.btbu.edu.cn

Abstract

The technical characteristics of various fluorine content detection methods in recent years are summarized,with three dimensions focused on,namely,detection principle,technical characteristics,and application status,to comprehensively describe domestic and international indirect detection techniques of total fluorine content in food packaging materials.The existing detection methods are sorted out according to the two links of sample pre -treatment and fluorine content determination,and the technical parameters and application scenarios are compared.In addition,key parameters of fluorine content detection techniques are analyzed and evaluated,such as accuracy,precision,stability,detection time,and cost -effectiveness.Suggestions are put forward for further improvement and optimization of the techniques.

Publication Date

4-25-2025

First Page

212

Last Page

220

DOI

10.13652/j.spjx.1003.5788.2025.60023

References

[1] SMITH E G.Fluoride,the environment,and human health [J].Perspectives in Biology and Medicine,2015,29(4):560-572.
[2] BOUKHRIS A,LAFFONT-SCHWOB I,RABIER J,et al.Changes in mesophyll element distribution and phytometabolite contents involved in fluoride tolerance of the arid gypsum-tolerant plant species Atractylis serratuloides Sieber ex Cass.(Asteraceae ) [J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research Intemational,2015,22(10):7 918-7 929.
[3] RENNER R.Growing concern over perfluorinated chemicals[J].Environmental Science & Technology,2001,35(7):154A-160A.
[4] BRUNN H,ARNOLD G,KÖRNER W,et al.PFAS:forever chemicals-persistent,bioaccumulative and mobile.Reviewing the status and the need for their phase out and remediation of contaminated sites [J].Environmental Sciences Europe,2023,35(1):1-50.
[5] FUGE R.Fluorine in the environment,a review of its sources and geochemistry [J].Applied Geochemistry,2019,100:393-406.
[6] BUCK R C,FRANKLIN J,BERGER U,et al.Perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances in the environment:terminology,classification,and origins [J].Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management,2011,7(4):513-541.
[7] LUBOJANSKI A,PIESIAK -PANCZYSZYN D,ZAKRZEWSKI W,et al.The safety of fluoride compounds and their effect on the human body:a narrative review [J].Materials,2023,16(3):1 242.
[8] RUXTON C.Fluoride in the UK diet [J].Nursing Standard,2014,28(49):52-59.
[9] 雷绍民,郭振华.氟污染的危害及含氟废水处理技术研究进展[J].金属矿山,2012 (4):152-155,159.LEI S M,GUO Z H.Hazards of fluoride pollution and technical research progress of treating fluoride-containing wastewater [J].Metal Mine,2012 (4):152-155,159
[10] 李祥志,曹文庚,李英,等.含氟地下水的危害、治理技术现状与进展 [J].中国地质,2024,51(2):457-482.LI X Z,CAO W G,LI Y,et al.Harmfulness of fluorine-bearing groundwater and its current situation and progress of treatment technology [J].Geology in China,2024,51(2):457-482.
[11] OUYANG Z X,YANG B J,YI J N,et al.Exposure to fluoride induces apoptosis in liver of ducks by regulating Cyt-C/Caspase 3/9 signaling pathway [J].Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2021,224:112662.
[12] ARABELA C R,ANTÍA L,PATRICIA L V,et al.Presence of perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS ) in food contact materials (FCM ) and its migration to food [J].Foods,2021,10(7):1 443.
[13] LOUREIRO V P,NGUYEN H K,QUIRÓS D B R A,et al.Identification and quantification of per- and polyfluorinated alkyl substances (PFAS ) migrating from food contact materials (FCM ) [J].Chemosphere,2024,360:142360.
[14] HAN Y Y,CAO X L.Research progress of perfluoroalkyl substances in edible oil:a review [J].Foods,2023,12(13):2 624.
[15] 刘勋涛,李春阳,陈汐昂,等.全氟化合物控制政策、识别控制技术及生态风险评估进展 [J].农业环境科学学报,2023,42(9):1 911-1 927.LIU X T,LI C Y,CHEN X A,et al.Development progress of perfluorinated compounds in control policy,identification and control technology,and ecological risk assessment [J].Journal of Agro-Environment Science,2023,42(9):1 911-1 927.
[16] STROSKI K M,SAPOZHNIKOVA Y.Analysis of per-and polyfluoroalkyl substances in plastic food storage bags by different analytical approaches [J].Journal of Chromatography Open,2023,4:100106.
[17] EZE G C,OKEKE S E,NWANKWO E C,et al.Emerging contaminants in food matrices:an overview of the occurrence,pathways,impacts and detection techniques of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances [J].Toxicology Reports,2024,12:436-447.
[18] 陈玲,杨帆,黄倩,等.食品接触制品中全氟和多氟化合物在各 国 的 法 规 差 异 分 析 [J].现 代 食 品,2024,30(7):118-121,125.CHEN L,YANG F,HUANG Q,et al.Analysis of differences in national regulations for perfluorinated and polyfluorinated compounds in food contact products [J].Modern Food,2024,30(7):118-121,125.
[19] ZABALETA I,NEGREIRA N,BIZKARGUENAGA E,et al.Screening and identification of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in microwave popcorn bags [J].Food Chemistry,2017,230:497-506.
[20] ZABALETA I,BIZKARGUENAGA E,BILBAO D,et al.Fast and simple determination of perfluorinated compounds and their potential precursors in different packaging materials [J].Talanta,2016,152:353-363.
[21] ZABALETA I,BIZKARGUENAGA E,PRIETO A,et al.Simultaneous determination of perfluorinated compounds and their potential precursors in mussel tissue and fish muscle tissue and liver samples by liquid chromatography-electrospray-tandem mass spectrometry [J].Journal of Chromatography A,2015,1 387:13-23.
[22] REVELO-MEJÍA I A,GUTIÉRREZ-IDROBO R,LÓPEZ-FERNÁNDEZ V A,et al.Fluoride levels in river water from the volcanic regions of Cauca (Colombia ) [J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2022,194(5):327.
[23] ARACELI D P,JAIMES A C,WAHL S,et al.Fluorine loss determination in bioactive glasses by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS ) [J].International Journal of Applied Glass Science,2021,12(2):213-221.
[24] BABOS D V,GARCIA S D R H,COLNAGO A L,et al.A simple,rapid,green and non-destructive 19 F time-domain NMR method for directly fluorine determination in powder of mineral supplements for cattle [J].Microchemical Journal,2020,1 531:104416.|[25] LIU R B,YIN Y S.Research progress on the related physical mechanism of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy [J].Chinese Optics,2024,17(1):1-19.
[26] PENG J Y,HE Y,YE L H,et al.Moisture influence reducing method for heavy metals detection in plant materials using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy:a case study for chromium content detection in rice leaves [J].Analytical Chemistry,2017,89(14):7 593-7 600.
[27] WIENS R C,MAURICE S,LASUE J,et al.Pre-flight calibration and initial data processing for the ChemCam laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy instrument on the mars science laboratory rover [J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B:Atomic Spectroscopy,2013,82:1-27.
[28] BUSSER B,MONCAYO S,COLL J L,et al.Elemental imaging using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy:a new and promising approach for biological and medical applications[J].Coordination Chemistry Reviews,2018,358:70-79.
[29] PETER L,STURM V,NOLL R.Liquid steel analysis with laser-induced breakdown spectrometry in the vacuum ultraviolet [J].Applied Optics,2003,42(30):6 199-6 204.
[30] VILLAS-BOAS P R,ROMANO R A,DE MENEZES FRANCO M A,et al.Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy to determine soil texture:a fast analytical technique [J].Geoderma,2016,263:195-202.
[31] HARMON R S,RUSSO R E,HARK R R.Applications of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy for geochemical and environmental analysis:a comprehensive review [J].Spectrochimica Acta Part B:Atomic Spectroscopy,2013,87:11-26.
[32] ÁLVAREZ C,PISONERO J,BORDEL N.Quantification of fluorite mass-content in powdered ores using a laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy method based on the detection of minor elements and CaF molecular bands [J/OL ].Spectrochimica Acta Part B:Atomic Spectroscopy,2014,100:123-128.
[33] 任维萍,冯淑琴,王珺,等.粉末样品的粒度对压片— X射线荧光光谱法测定炉渣准确度的影响 [J].冶金分析,2017,37(1):21-25.REN W P,FENG S Q,WANG J,et al.Influence of particle size of powdered sample on the determination accuracy of slag by X-ray fluorescence spectrometry with pressed powder pellet[J].Metallurgical Analysis,2017,37(1):21-25.
[34] 赵文志,张填昊,卢兵,等.粉末压片制样—波长色散 X射线荧光光谱法测定土壤和水系沉积物中溴氯氟磷硫 [J].冶金分析,2021,41(4):27-33.ZHAO W Z,ZHANG T H,LU B,et al.Determination of bromine,chlorine,fluorine,phosphorus and sulfur in soil and stream sediment by wavelength dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry with pressed powder pellet [J].Metallurgical Analysis,2021,41(4):27-33.
[35] 果秀敏,杨秀敏,解晓东,等.氧弹燃烧—氟离子选择电极法测定蔬菜中的氟 [J].河北农业大学学报,2009,32(5):98-100,104.GUO X M,YANG X M,XIE X D,et al.Determination of fluoride in vegetables by using oxygen bombfluoride ion-selective electrode method [J].Journal of Agricultural University of Hebei,2009,32(5):98-100,104.
[36] 周密,韩智,朱正伟,等.核磁共振波谱法结合氧弹燃烧测定茶叶中的总氟 [J].食品与机械,2021,37(4):58-62.ZHOU M,HAN Z,ZHU Z W,et al.Determination of total fluorine in tea by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy combined with oxygen bomb combustion [J].Food & Machinery,2021,37(4):58-62.
[37] 陈伟,张宏亮,张吉范,等.生物质电站固体生物质燃料中氯含量的测定 [J].化学研究与应用,2017,29(7):1 083-1 088.CHEN W,ZHANG H L,ZHANG J F,et al.Determination the chlorine content of solid biomass fuels in biomass power plant[J].Chemical Research and Application,2017,29(7):1 083-1 088.
[38] 张鸟飞,陈雯,郑程,等.水蒸气蒸馏—离子色谱法测定含铁尘泥中的氟和氯 [J].中国无机分析化学,2021,11(6):12-16.ZHANG N F,CHEN W,ZHENG C,et al.Determination of fluoride and chloride in iron-bearing dust and sludge by water vapor distillation-ion chromatography [J].Chinese Journal of Inorganic Analytical Chemistry,2021,11(6):12-16.
[39] 齐庆杰,刘剑,刘建忠,等.煤中氟高温燃烧水解法测定影响因素实验研究 [J].辽宁工程技术大学学报,2002 (4):401-404.QI Q J,LIU J,LIU J Z,et al.Experimental research on influence factors on determination of fluorine in coals by combustion-hydrolysis/ISE method [J].Journal of Liaoning Technical University,2002 (4):401-404.
[40] 赵怀颖,孙德忠,曹亚萍,等.高温燃烧水解—离子色谱法测定植物样品中的氟 [J].岩矿测试,2011,30(6):761-767.ZHAO H Y,SUN D Z,CAO YP,et al.Quantification of fluorine in plants by high temperature combustion hydrolysis-ion chromatography [J].Rock and Mineral Analysis,2011,30(6):761-767.
[41] 李颖娜,徐志彬,张志伟.高温水解—离子色谱法测定铁矿石中氟和氯 [J].冶金分析,2016,36(6):23-28.LI Y N,XU Z B,ZHANG Z W,et al.Determination of fluorine and chlorine in iron ores by pyrohydrolysision chromatography [J].Metallurgical Analysis,2016,36(6):23-28.
[42] 孙儒瑞,王军华,高孙慧.高温水解—离子色谱法同时测定固体生物质燃料中有害元素的研究 [J].应用化工,2019,48(9):2 264-2 267,2 270.SUN R R,WANG J H,GAO S H,et al.Simultaneous determination of harmful elements in solid biomass fuel by high temperature hydrolysis-ion chromatography [J].Applied Chemical Industry,2019,48(9):2 264-2 267,2 270.
[43] 王诗语,凌凤香,韩博等.管式炉燃烧—离子色谱法测定固体生物质燃料中硫和氯 [J].理化检验 (化学分册 ),2020,56(7):755-759.WANG S Y,LING F X,HAN B,et al.IC Determination of sulfur and chlorine in solid biomass fuel with tube furnace combustion [J].Physical Testing and Chemical Analysis (Part B:Chemical Analysis ),2020,56(7):755-759.
[44] 李静,关玉春,王琳等.碱熔—离子选择电极法测定固体废物中氟 [J].冶金分析,2021,41(8):84-90.LI J,GUAN Y C,WANG L,et al.Determination of fluorine in solid waste by alkali fusion-ion selective electrode method [J].Metallurgical Analysis,2021,41(8):84-90.
[45] 双龙.高温灰化—酸溶—离子选择性电极法测定生态地球化学评价生物样品中的痕量氟 [J].化学试剂,2022,44(10):1 500-1 505.SHUANG L.Determination of trace fluorine in biological samples for eco-geochemical assessment by ion selective electrode method with high temperature ashing acid digestion[J].Chemical Reagents,2022,44(10):1 500-1 505.
[46] IGNACIO M C C D,CURTZWILER G W,EARLY M R,et al.Ion selective electrode (ISE) method for determination of total fluorine and total organic fluorine in packaging substrates [J].Methods and Protocols,2023,6(1):10.
[47] 唐韵熙,白亚敏,刘露露,等.超高效液相色谱—串联质谱法同时测定动物源性食品中 21种全氟类化合物残留 [J].食品与机械,2023,39(7):29-39.TANG Y X,BAI Y M,LIU L L,et al.Simultaneous determination of 21 perfluorinated compounds in animal derived food by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry [J].Food & Machinery,2023,39(7):29-39.
[48] PESAKOVA V,BROZMANOVA H,SISTIK P,et al.Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry method for determination of total and free teriflunomide concentration in serum of patients with multiple sclerosis [J].Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis,2023,224:115173.
[49] 李小莉,李庆霞,安树清,等.X射线荧光光谱法测定土壤样品中的氟 [J].分析化学,2019,47(11):1 864-1 869.LI X L,LI Q X,AN S Q,et al.Determination of fluorine in soil sample by X-ray fluorescence spectrometry [J].Chinese Journal of Analytical Chemistry,2019,47(11):1 864-1 869.
[50] KUZ'MINA T G,TRONEVA M A,ROMASHOVA T V.Role of petrogenic elements in the excitation of X-ray fluorescence of fluorine [J].Journal of Analytical Chemistry,2020,75(7):896-901.
[51] VALKOVIĆ O,JAKŠIĆ M,FAZINIĆ S,et al.Quality control of PIXE and PIGE nuclear analytical techniques in geological and environmental applications [J].Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B:Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms,1995,99(1/2/3/4):372-375.
[52] DAS S,DE OLIVEIRA L M,DA SILVA E,et al.Fluoride concentrations in traditional and herbal teas:health risk assessment [J].Environmental Pollution,2017,231:779-784.
[53] ELEKES Z,UZONYI I,GRATUZE B,et al.Contribution of PIGE technique to the study of obsidian glasses [J].Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B:Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms,2000,161/162/163:836-841.
[54] NOMITA DEVI K,NANDAKUMAR SARMA H.PIXE-PIGE analysis of some Indian medicinal plants [J].Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B:Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms,2010,268(11/12):2 144-2 147.
[55] DHORGE P S,GIRKAR P S,SHARMA A D,et al.Application of in situ current normalized particle induced gamma-ray emission (PIGE ) method for determination of total fluorine concentration in sediment samples from different geological provinces and its relevance to fluoride contamination [J].Geochemistry,2020,80(4):125551.

Download

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.